(Feb. 25, 2009, Aguanomics)

Readers will know that I favor neither public nor private (investor-owned) provision of water, since the problems of ownership structure are less important than the problems of monopoly. (And the solution to monopoly — if not competition — is careful community monitoring.)

For more evidence on what does and does not matter, read this group project [PDF] by five UC Santa Barbara masters students.

Our research identified two primary differences between the public and privately owned water utilities in Thousand Oaks:

  1. The privately owned water providers operate with greater efficiency than the public utility on three of the four indices of operational efficiency we evaluated;
  2. The publicly-owned water provider charged significantly lower rates in the privately owned water providers for the 15 year period examined.

There was no significant difference between the providers on the basis of infrastructure investment and condition, water quality, water conservation, or customer satisfaction.Read the whole report (232 pp) to get a serious dose of facts.

Bottom Line: There are tradeoffs between public and private ownership. If they’re weren’t, ALL water would be provided by one or the other!

(Original Post Here)

Bookmark Me!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Furl
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis

Related posts:

  1. When You have a Water Monopoly, Who is Your Overseer?: Some People are Just Plain against For-Profit Water Companies, for the Wrong Reasons; Cheap Water may be a Benefit, but it’s Part of the Problem (Aguanomics) (Feb. 28, 2009, Aguanomics) Aquadoc’s review of Blue Gold attracted...
  2. In Water Industry, Public Vs. Private Debate Heats Up (InternationalRivers) (Feb. 24, 2009, International Rivers) This March, Istanbul Turkey will...
  3. Australia Ahead of California on Its Water Markets: Every Household Metered for Water Down Under; Water Licenses, Not Water Rights; Better Indoor & Underground Water Efficiency; Less Water Consumption Per Capita — Zetland: Cheap Water’s Result is Water Shortage (David Zetland, Aguanomics) (March 4, 2009, David Zetland, Aguanomics) RT writes: I am...
  4. A War of Water: American Cities Vs. Private Companies — Audio (AlterNet) (Jan. 29, 2009, AlterNet) The privatization of public water supplies...
  5. Unregulated Groundwater in California State’s Biggest Water Policy Problem, Says David Zetland: How Price or Market Water Sans Knowledge of Supply and Demand? (Aguanomics) (Feb. 24, 2009, Aguanomics) The battle is getting started: The...